How to pick fair random teams with an odd number of players

Doubles needs four people. Pickleball, roundnet, beach volleyball 2s: same math. Then five people show up, or seven, and someone has to sit. The awkward part isn’t the sitting. It’s deciding who sits, who plays with whom, and doing it without the same person always ending up on the bench or always stuck with the strongest player.

Here are the setups that work, from five players up to “half the park showed up.”

Five players, one court: the perfect rotation

Five is the best odd number, because it has a schedule where everyone sits exactly once and every pair plays together exactly once. Name the players A to E:

  1. A sits: B + C vs D + E

  2. B sits: A + D vs C + E

  3. C sits: A + E vs B + D

  4. D sits: A + C vs B + E

  5. E sits: A + B vs C + D

Five games, four games each, one rest each. There are ten possible partner pairs among five people, and each game uses two of them, so five games cover all ten once. No repeats, no favorites.

Write it on your phone’s notes or a piece of tape on the paddle bag. If you play to 11 in pickleball or to 21 in roundnet, a full round fits in a normal session. When someone arrives late, they slot in as the next person to sit.

Three players: play two against one

With three, nobody has to sit. Rotate a two-against-one game, where the solo player takes on a pair, and switch who’s solo every game. In pickleball this is sometimes called cutthroat or Canadian doubles. Each player takes a turn alone, so it evens out over three games. Keep score individually if you want a winner.

Six, seven, or more on one court: use a sit-out queue

Past five, a perfect schedule gets long. The simple fair rule is a queue:

  • Whoever has sat out longest goes in next. Keep the queue on a whiteboard, a phone, or by lining up paddles in order along the fence.

  • Shuffle teams every game. Random teams beat captains picking. Nobody gets picked last, and the strongest pair doesn’t stay together all night.

  • Winners don’t stay on. “Winners stay” feels fun but it means the same people play all day. If your group likes it, cap it at two wins in a row.

With seven players on one court, three sit each game. That’s a lot of sitting, so shorten games (play to 7 or 9) to keep the queue moving.

Two courts and an odd number

Fill both courts first and keep one sit-out queue across them. When a game ends on either court, the players coming off join the back of the queue and the front of the queue goes in. Reshuffle partners each time so people mix between courts.

If skill levels differ a lot, it’s fine to agree on one “challenge court” and one “social court,” but keep the queue shared so nobody gets parked.

Making “random” actually fair

Random is fair on average, not every single game. Three tips keep it fair in practice:

  1. Separate “who sits” from “who partners.” Decide the sit-out first, using the queue or the five-player schedule. Then randomize the four (or six) who are playing. Picking both at random means someone can sit twice in a row by pure luck.

  2. Reshuffle on request, once. If a draw puts the two strongest players together, allow one reshuffle without anyone needing to explain why.

  3. Track a few results. Even a rough tally shows whether one pairing keeps blowing everyone out, which is your cue to stop random-drawing that pair.

Doing it on a phone

Plenty of groups use a notes app and a coin. If you’d rather tap a button, Next Up is a free iPhone app that does the shuffle: check in who’s there, pick 2v2, 3v3, 4v4 or “Any,” and it draws random teams, with a one-tap reshuffle, a coin flip for first serve, and a history of who won. With more players than spots, it picks who plays at random and doesn’t remember who sat last time, so for strict fairness uncheck whoever’s turn it is to sit, then shuffle the rest.

The short version

  • Five players: use the five-game rotation above.

  • Three: two against one, rotate the solo player.

  • Six or more: one sit-out queue, longest-waiting goes in, reshuffle teams every game.

  • Decide who sits first, then randomize partners.

Fair teams take about ten seconds once the group agrees on the rule. Agree on it before the first game, not after the third loss.